Overfitting and Underfitting in AI Models

AnneMarie DeBergh

10 months ago

Overfitting and Underfitting in AI Models

Introduction

Overfitting and underfitting are two types of errors that can affect the performance and accuracy of AI models. Overfitting occurs when a model learns too much from the training data and fails to generalize to new data. Underfitting occurs when a model learns too little from the training data and fails to capture the underlying patterns of the data. Both issues can lead to poor results and unreliable predictions. To illustrate this, let’s use an analogy of fitting a curve to a set of points:

Imagine that you have a set of points that represent some relationship between two variables, such as the height and weight of a group of people. You want to find a curve that best fits these points, so that you can use it to estimate the weight of a new person given their height. However, you have different options for choosing the type and complexity of the curve. For example, you can use a straight line, a quadratic curve, or a higher-order polynomial. How do you decide which one to use?

If you use a straight line, you might end up with a curve that is too simple and does not capture the variation in the data. This is an example of underfitting. The line will have a high error on both the training data and the new data and will not be able to make accurate predictions. On the other hand, if you use a higher-order polynomial, you might end up with a curve that is too complex and fits the training data perfectly but does not generalize well to new data. This is an example of overfitting. The curve will have a low error on the training data, but a high error on the new data, and will not be able to adapt to different situations.

The ideal curve is somewhere in between, a curve that is neither too simple nor too complex, and that can balance the tradeoff between fitting the training data and generalizing to new data. This is the goal of AI development, to find the optimal model that can avoid both overfitting and underfitting. In this blog, we will explore these concepts in more detail, and learn how to diagnose and fix them in our AI models.

Understanding overfitting

Overfitting is a common problem in AI development, especially when dealing with complex models and large datasets. Overfitting occurs when a model learns too much from the training data and becomes overly specific to it. As a result, the model loses its ability to generalize to new data and performs poorly on it. Overfitting can be caused by several factors, such as:

Using a model that is too complex for the data. For example, using a deep neural network with many layers and parameters for a simple classification task.
Using a dataset that is too small or too noisy for the model. For example, using a dataset that has only a few examples or that contains outliers and errors.
Training the model for too long or with too high a learning rate. For example, using a gradient descent algorithm that updates the model parameters too frequently or too drastically.

The consequences of overfitting

Overfitting problems can be severe, as the model becomes unreliable and inaccurate on new data. Some of the signs of overfitting are:

A large gap between the training error and the test error. For example, the model achieves a high accuracy on the training data, but a low accuracy on the test data.
A high variance in the model performance across different datasets. For example, the model performs well on some test datasets, but poorly on others.
A lack of interpretability and explainability of the model. For example, the model produces complex and convoluted decision boundaries that are hard to understand and justify.

Recognizing underfitting

Underfitting is the opposite of overfitting, but it is equally problematic for AI development. Underfitting occurs when a model learns too little from the training data and becomes overly general and simplistic. As a result, the model fails to capture the underlying patterns and relationships of the data and performs poorly on both the training data and the new data. Underfitting can be caused by several factors, such as:

Using a model that is too simple for the data. For example, using a linear regression model for a nonlinear regression task.
Using a dataset that is too limited or too irrelevant for the model. For example, using a dataset that has only a few features or that does not represent the target population.
Training the model for too short or with too low a learning rate. For example, using a gradient descent algorithm that updates the model parameters too infrequently or too mildly.

The consequences of underfitting

Underfitting can be serious, as the model becomes ineffective and inaccurate on both the training data and the new data. Some of the signs of underfitting are:

A high error on both the training data and the test data. For example, the model achieves a low accuracy on both the training data and the test data.
A low variance in the model performance across different datasets. For example, the model performs consistently poorly on all test datasets.
A lack of specificity and sensitivity of the model. For example, the model produces simple and generic decision boundaries that are not able to distinguish between different classes or outcomes.

Diagnosing and fixing the problem.

Fortunately, there are several techniques and strategies that can help us detect and address overfitting and underfitting in our AI models. Some of the most common and effective ones are:

Using techniques for measuring and comparing the model performance on the training data and the test data. For example, using metrics like accuracy, precision, recall, and F1-score, and plotting learning curves and validation curves.
Using techniques for visualizing and analyzing the model behavior and output. For example, using confusion matrices, ROC curves, and AUC scores, and plotting decision boundaries and feature importance.
Using techniques for modifying and improving the model architecture and parameters. For example, using regularization techniques like L1, L2, and dropout, and data augmentation techniques like flipping, cropping, and rotating.
Using techniques for adjusting and optimizing the model training process and hyperparameters. For example, using early stopping techniques like validation loss and patience, and hyperparameter tuning techniques like grid search and random search.

It’s a balancing act

The goal of AI development is to find the optimal balance between complexity and simplicity, between fitting and generalizing, between bias and variance. This is not an easy task, as there is no one-size-fits-all solution for every problem and dataset. However, there is a useful concept that can guide us in this quest: The bias-variance tradeoff. The bias-variance tradeoff is a fundamental concept in machine learning that describes the relationship between the model complexity and the model error. The model complexity refers to how flexible and expressive the model is, and how well it can fit the data. The model error refers to how much the model deviates from the true function that generates the data, and how well it can generalize to new data. The bias-variance tradeoff states that:

A high model complexity leads to a low bias and a high variance. This means that the model can fit the training data very well, but it can also overfit the data and perform poorly on new data.
A low model complexity leads to a high bias and a low variance. This means that the model can generalize to new data very well, but it can also underfit the data and perform poorly on both the training data and the new data.
An optimal model complexity leads to a balance between bias and variance. This means that the model can fit the training data reasonably well and generalize to new data reasonably well.

Tools and techniques

The bias-variance tradeoff helps us understand the tradeoff between overfitting and underfitting, and how to find the sweet spot that minimizes the total error. However, finding this sweet spot is not always straightforward, as it depends on many factors, such as the data quality, the model type, and the hyperparameters. Therefore, we need to use advanced techniques and tools that can help us fine-tune our models and achieve the best performance possible. Some of these techniques and tools are:

Using ensemble methods that combine multiple models to reduce the variance and increase the robustness. For example, using bagging, boosting, and stacking techniques.
Using cross-validation methods that split the data into multiple subsets and use them for training and testing. For example, using k-fold, leave-one-out, and stratified techniques.
Using automated machine learning methods that search for the best model and hyperparameters automatically. For example, using AutoML, AutoKeras, and AutoSklearn tools.

Conclusion

Overfitting and underfitting are two common and important issues that affect the performance and accuracy of AI models. They are caused by different factors, such as the model complexity, the data quality, and the training process. They have different consequences, such as poor generalization, high errors, and low interpretability. They can be detected and fixed by using various techniques and strategies, such as measuring, visualizing, modifying, and optimizing the model. They can be balanced by using the concept of the bias-variance tradeoff, and by using advanced techniques and tools, such as ensemble methods, cross-validation methods, and automated machine learning methods.By understanding and avoiding these pitfalls, we can develop more effective and reliable AI models that can solve complex problems, make accurate predictions, and automate tasks. We can also become better AI developers, who can design, evaluate, and improve their models with confidence and skill. If you are interested in learning more about these topics, here are some resources that you can check out: